GraphoGame Rime

GraphoGame Rime is a computer game designed to teach pupils to read by developing their phonological awareness and phonic skills. Pupils work on individual devices supervised in small groups by a teacher or teaching assistant. The game is designed to adjust the difficulty to challenge the learner at an appropriate level. 

local_library

Literacy

Subject

accessibility

Key Stage 1

Key stage

EEF Summary

There is strong evidence that developing phonological skills is an effective way to improve reading outcomes. GraphoGame Rime builds on this evidence, and on specific research which suggests that teaching children to recognise ‘rime units’ in families of words (for example “c-at”, “m-at”, “s-at”) develops a particular phonological skill which helps pupils learning to read. Previous, developer-led studies of GraphoGame Rime suggested that the game led to gains in reading skills, but these studies were small and had limitations. EEF and Wellcome Trust funded this project in order to rigorously test the impact of the game on Year 2 pupils.

This study provided no evidence that GraphoGame Rime was effective at improving reading outcomes over and above business-as-usual, and this is a highly secure result. Because the project focused on pupils who had been identified by the Year 1 phonics screening check as having low skills, comparison group pupils received other literacy support, including small-group and one-to-one activities, for similar amounts of time to that spent playing GraphoGame Rime by the pupils using it.

Teachers found the intervention easy to implement and considered it highly engaging.

EEF has no plans for a further trial of GraphoGame Rime, but will continue to consider other projects which use evidence-based approaches to raise literacy. 

Research Results

Reading

-1
Months' Progress
Evidence Strength

Reading (Ever 6 FSM)

0
Months' Progress

N/A

Were the schools in the trial similar to my school?

The trial involved 15 primary schools in Cambridgeshire.

60% of the schools were rated as Good by Ofsted, and 40% as Requires Improvement.

Around a third of the pupils had been eligible for FSM at some point since starting school, and around 60% of the pupils were boys (the disproportionate number of boys was due to lower average scores in the phonics screening check). 

Could I implement this in my school?

GraphoGame Rime is not currently available to purchase in England, but is expected to be available in summer 2018 for a small licence fee.

Participating schools require PCs, laptops or tablets and headphones to allow pupils to play the game without disturbing their classmates.

account_circle

SLT, Teachers, TAs

Delivered by

group

Parents

Participant group

date_range

12 Weeks

Intervention length

How much will it cost?

The estimated average cost per school per year for the intervention as delivered in this trial was around £770, or £48 per pupil per year when averaged over three years. The main financial costs of delivering the intervention were the costs associated with delivering training and on-going technical support. 

£

£48

Cost per pupil

people_outline

1

No. of Teachers/TAs

today

0.5 Days

Training time per staff member

Evaluation info

Schools

15

Pupils

398

Key Stage

Key Stage 1

Start date

January 2015

End date

May 2018

Type of trial

Efficacy Trial

Evaluation Conclusions

  1. The trial found no evidence that GraphoGame Rime improves pupils’ reading or spelling test scores when compared to business-as-usual. This result has very high security.

  2. The same is true when looking specifically at pupils who have ever been eligible for FSM. The security of this result is lower because the number of pupils is smaller.

  3. Teachers reported that they felt sufficiently well trained and found the intervention easy to set up and implement. Teachers, senior leaders and pupils considered GraphoGame Rime highly engaging, motivational and enjoyable. Findings suggest that all schools implemented the programme with a relatively good level of fidelity.

  4. Because the game was tested against business as usual, comparison group pupils received other literacy support, including small-group and one-to-one literacy activities, for similar amounts of time to that spent on GraphoGame Rime by pupils using it. This means the lack of observed impact shows that the intervention is no more or less effective than the support the comparison pupils received.


  1. Updated: 10th May, 2018

    Printable project summary

    1 MB pdf - EEF-graphogame-rime.pdf

Full project description

keyboard_arrow_down